Southern States PBA
Join Now

PBA member petitions U.S. Supreme Court on First Amendment retaliation issue

PBA member Mark McCaffrey, formerly employed by the Loudoun County (Va.) Sheriff’s Office, filed a petition for a writ of certiorari with the United States Supreme Court in September.  McCaffrey  and his PBA-assigned attorney, Robert J. Cynkar of the firm McSweeney, Cynkar & Kachouroff in Great Falls, Va., are pursuing civil relief for McCaffrey in regard to his December 2015 termination by Loudoun County Sheriff Mark Chapman.  The civil action alleges violations of the First Amendment in that McCaffrey was terminated in retaliation for McCaffrey’s support for Chapman’s opponent for the Republican nomination for sheriff.  

 

McCaffrey’s support was demonstrated via a sign in his yard supporting the candidate and his acting as a delegate to the Republican convention in which the Republican candidate for sheriff was chosen.  According to his lawsuit, McCaffrey never spoke publicly about the election nor did he in any other way campaign for Chapman’s opponent.  After the Republican convention, Sheriff Chapman stated that he knew McCaffrey was in attendance and said, “I’m going to get him.”  McCaffrey received a letter on December 10, 2015, stating that his appointment as deputy ended at midnight on December 31, 2015.  He had received uniformly outstanding reviews during his service at the department.

 

The petition to the Supreme Court comes after the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the sheriff and Loudoun County.  The petition states the following reasons for the Supreme Court to grant review:

1) The Fourth Circuit’s holding that Loudoun County deputy sheriffs are subject to partisan termination merits review because it is incorrect and in conflict with decisions of this Court and of other circuits;

2) The Fourth Circuit’s ruling that the Pickering-Connick balancing test for free-speech claims tilts in favor of the government as a matter of law if the claimant’s position falls within the Elrod-Branti exception was incorrect and in conflict with decisions of this Court and other circuits; and

3) This case is an excellent vehicle for review of exceptionally important issues and addressing the disarray among the precedents governing them.

 

Review by the Supreme Court would provide an opportunity to settle discrepancies in how terminations for deputy sheriffs on the basis of political activity are viewed.  In the Fourth Circuit’s decision on this matter, the longstanding view of deputy sheriffs being considered policymakers for the sheriff with expectations of loyalty to that sheriff was upheld.

 

In an effort to persuade the Supreme Court to review the McCaffrey case, SSPBA submitted an amicus brief prepared by PBA attorneys J. Michael McGuinness and Megan Milliken.  Among the arguments made in the amicus brief is the following:  “Deputy sheriffs must not be singled out, as an inferior class, for the elimination of fundamental First Amendment rights enjoyed by other Americans.”

Southern States PBA News
ALPBA scholarship recipient plans to hit the ground in college

December 11, 2024

Maddie Cone, Auburn University freshman, is eager to show her love for the outside world with a degree in agricultural education. "I chose this field to create change in the world through my love for agriculture and education," she said. "Receiving this scholarship is a great honor," she said. "Law enforcement runs deep in my family. This scholarship not only helps to alleviate the financial burdens of college, but it also shows the great support PBF has for the families of law enforcement." Maddie said she is excited about her future and teaching young students to love and appreciate the earth as much as she always has.

more
Social Security Fairness Act

The Social Security Fairness Act has passed the House and is now in the Senate! Learn more about what you can do.

more
NCPBA Scholarship Recipient Trey Hinson

November 25, 2024

Whatever Piedmont High School graduate Trey Hinson tackles, he conquers. Next up, college and a law enforcement career in the footsteps of his father, NCPBA member Jason Hinson. Trey has earned two scholarships, in fact, the NCBA Division scholarship and a Foundation Scholarship, earmarked for those students pursuing a degree in criminal justice or criminology. He started college at Appalachian State University in fall of 2024.

more